Must, Might or Can’t? Making Deductions

Read a little. Notice the pattern. Use it your way.

B1/B2 · UNIT 6

Let’s make it clear.

Show how strongly evidence supports a conclusion about now or the past.

01 · THE IDEA

What are you trying to say?

Use must for a strong positive deduction, might or could for a possibility, and can’t for something you judge impossible. These meanings concern evidence, not obligation or permission.

SEE IT IN A SENTENCEThe lights are on: she must be home. She might be working. She can’t be asleep if she is on a call.

02 · BUILD IT

Keep the pattern handy.

Patterns and examples
UsePatternExample
Strong positive conclusionmust + base / must have + participleShe must be tired. / She must have left.
Open possibilitymay/might/could + base / have + participleHe might be home. / He might have forgotten.
Strong negative conclusioncan’t + base / can’t have + participleIt can’t be true. / It can’t have happened.
In-progress possibilitymight be + -ing / might have been + -ingShe might be working.

03 · EXAMPLES & MEANING

Small changes. Different messages.

The modal expresses your judgment

Deductive must means the evidence strongly suggests a conclusion; it is different from an obligation. Might, may and could leave a possibility open. Can’t expresses a strong negative conclusion. These forms do not map reliably to fixed percentages, and certainty of belief is not proof.

Her coat is here. She must be nearby.
The coat supports the inference.
She might be at the café.
A possible explanation without a strong conclusion.

Locate the inferred situation in time

Use modal + base form for a current state or future possibility; modal + have + participle looks back at a past event. For an activity in progress, add be + -ing or have been + -ing. Mustn’t normally expresses prohibition, not the opposite of a deduction with must.

The lights are off. They might have gone home.
A possible earlier event explains the current evidence.
He can’t have written it yesterday; he was away.
Evidence argues against a past possibility.

04 · COMMON MISTAKES

A small fix makes the difference.

Instead ofHe must to be tired.

Try thisHe must be tired.

A modal takes a base verb without to.

Instead ofShe mustn’t be home. [negative deduction]

Try thisShe can’t be home.

Can’t is the normal strong negative deduction.

TAKE IT WITH YOU

Now make it your English.

Choose an example above. Change the people, place or situation to make a sentence about your own life. Read it aloud, then check the pattern again.

Saved only in this browser. You can change it anytime.